Don’t Miss the Goods

Get delicious recipes delivered to your inbox.

Made this Recipe?

We’d love to see your photos and hear about how it turned out!

Join the Conversation 36 Comments
Close

Favorite Vanilla Cake

January 23, 2017 | By Jeremy Scheck | 36 Comments

What makes this cake so perfect?

  • The reverse creaming method (mixing softened butter into the flour mixture, not just with sugar) used gives the cake a fine crumb
  • The cake uses half vegetable oil (for moistness) and half butter (for flavor and crumb structure)
  • The greek yogurt (or sour cream) tenderizes and moistens the cake
  • The cake flour (I use Swans Down or King Arthur) gives it a lighter texture

Adapted and simplified from http://www.cupcakeproject.com/

Yield: Three 8" or 9" layers or 40 cupcakes.

Favorite Vanilla Cake

Ingredients

  • 2-2/3 cups (350g) cake flour (not self rising)
  • 3 teaspoons baking powder (this is equal to 1 tablespoon)
  • 1 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1 teaspoon kosher salt
  • 2 cups (450g) granulated sugar
  • 1 stick (113g) butter at room temperature
  • 4 eggs
  • 2/3 cup (150g) full fat Greek yogurt (or sour cream)
  • 1/2 cup (120ml) flavorless vegetable oil, such as canola, avocado, or grapeseed
  • 2 tbsp vanilla extract
  • 1–1/3 cups (320ml) whole milk

Instructions

  1. Preheat the oven to 350° F.
  2. Butter and flour the round cake pans you have chosen to use. To be sure my cakes release easily from the tin, I line the bottom with a circle of parchment paper. For best results, grease the pans, add the parchment paper to the bottom, grease again, then flour.
  3. In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with a paddle attachment or with hand beaters, combine the flour, baking powder, baking soda, salt, and sugar.
  4. Beat the softened butter into the dry mixture until it is in tiny crumbs resembling sand well dispersed in the flour mixture.
  5. In a large measuring cup or small bowl, briefly whisk together the the oil, eggs, yogurt, and vanilla. Pour the wet mixture into the dry. Beat until incorporated.
  6. Pour in the milk and mix until smooth. The batter should be quite thin.
  7. Divide the cake batter among the prepared pans.
  8. Bake for 20-30 minutes, or until the cakes are lightly browned and spring back when lightly pressed. Keep in mind that all ovens are different and that the amount of cake pans you choose affect baking time.
  9. Cool in the tin for 15 mins, and then take the cakes out and cool completely on the rack before icing. You may need to run a knife around the edges to help release the cake.
  10. Use my 5 tips for icing a cake.

36 Comments
Add a Comment

Comments

  1. As an avid baker with frustratingly high standards, I don’t think I have ever been happy enough with a recipe to leave a review. Jeremy’s cakes – all of them – are without a doubt the BEST cake recipes I have ever tried. I will never cream butter and sugar together again.

  2. This cake is, as the name entailed, my new favorite and go to vanilla cake. I cut the sugar in half to pair with a sweeter icing— loved it 🙂 thank you tiktok algorithm

  3. This is now my favorite vanillla cake recipe! I was weary of the reverse creaming method, but it produced such a moist and fluffy cake! I also found the process easier than the regular creaming method. Such a great recipe!

  4. I have made so many vanilla cake recipes and this has so far been my favourite! So light and fluffy but still perfectly moist. This is my new go to!!

  5. Hi! Could I do the reverse creaming method with a danish dough whisk or a electric hand mixer? Also do you use a simple syrup when getting ready to frost?

  6. Hi! Would I be able to do the reverse creaming method with a danish dough whisk or a electric hand mixer. Also do you use a simple syrup before getting ready to frost?

  7. hey! if I were to use around 6 inch pans (maybe just a 2 layer cake?) do you reccomend for me to half the recipe?

  8. I tried out this cake along with Jeremy’s lemon curd recipe for my birthday and it was perfect! Definitely mine and my families go to cake recipe from now on.

  9. i scoured the internet for a simple fluffy cake recipe, this was the best I could find!!! first time doing reverse creaming and it turned out so well. thank you Jeremy!! <3

  10. Made this yesterday for my sister’s birthday with the lemon curd filling, whip cream frosting and fresh berries on top. It was fantastic! Will definitely make many times again! Love your recipes Jeremy Scheck!

  11. I love this cake! It is moist with great flavor, and it keeps this texture even for a few days, instead of getting dry and crumbly like many other cake recipes that I’ve tried.

  12. this cake is by far my familys favorite. Ive made many different vanilla cakes, and this is the best. Its so easy to make, and it always comes out perfect. I usually pair it with a good buttercream, and it is the perfect sweetness.

  13. I made this cake and it is very light and tasty. But when I deed the avocado oil it made the cake greenish, so I would use a different oil next time.

  14. I tried out about five different cake recipes, one that I even got from a professional chef and have landed in this one all my go-to. It makes a silky yummy batter that cooks into a fluffy cake that keeps its structure. I have done it with both Cake and All-purpose flour and found that cake flour is better, but All purpose works too. This pairs great with a lemon curd or berry jam to bring tangy or sweet flavor. This batch made enough for two six inch pans and 12 cupcakes. I had my doubts, but this is it; the best cake recipe.

  15. I have tried many vanilla cake recipes and none of them have been up to my standards, they are too dense or collapse or way to sweet so I was skeptical to try this one. It is by far the best vanilla cake I have ever made and so light and fluffy!! 10/10 would recommend

  16. This cake SLAPPED – the first time I made it I accidentally used twice the amount of butter because I thought one block of Kerrygold was one stick 💔 nonetheless it was really good, kind of like a pound cake, and my roommates and I are still alive and kicking so no complaints there. The second time I used the right amount of butter and it was amazing! Jeremy is a bhaddie for this recipe

  17. I consider myself and fairly skilled baker however I could never get cake right till I found this recipe. This is it, you have found it, the best cake. I like to divide the batter into 3 six inch pans and then cut each into thirds so I get three whole cakes out of this, great recipe for wanting to experiment with icing and fillings. chef’s kiss.

  18. I used this recipe to make a bunch of cupcakes (30+), and me and a couple friends destroyed them in a weekend. We ate half of them without frosting, they’re just the right amount of sweet and sugary and buttery, and the texture is amazing. 10/10, favorite yellow/vanilla cake recipe.

  19. I used this recipe to make a bunch of cupcakes (30+), and me and a couple friends destroyed them in a weekend. We ate half of them without frosting, they’re just the right amount of sweet and sugary and buttery, and the texture is amazing. 10/10, favorite yellow/vanilla cake recipe!

Share Your Thoughts

Your email address will not be published.

Get This & More

Get delicious recipes delivered to your inbox.

@ScheckEats on Instagram Skip to Recipe